Am I a Musician or a Gear Collector?

Am I a Musician or a Gear Collector?

Am I a Musician or a Gear Collector?

Why your growing gear collection might be killing your creative flow — and how to get back to actually making music.

Last updated: Apr 16, 2025

Marvin Cavanaugh
Marvin Cavanaugh
Marvin Cavanaugh

Written by Marvin Cavanaugh

When Does Inspiration Become Hoarding?

It started small. A MIDI controller here, a plugin bundle there. One new synth — because that one patch on the demo video gave me chills. Then a field recorder. Then a groovebox I swore would fix my workflow. By the time the second set of studio monitors showed up, I had to ask myself the question I’d been avoiding for months:

Am I actually making music — or just collecting the tools for it?

This isn’t a post about minimalism. It’s about honesty. Because at some point, the gear that once unlocked creativity started to clog it. My studio looked great. My hard drive? A graveyard of unfinished ideas. And every time I sat down to write, I found myself scrolling presets, testing cables, rearranging shelves. Everything except hitting record.

The Seduction of “Creative Potential”

The gear world runs on promises. New tools sell us a vision of who we could be — more expressive, more efficient, more legit. And hey, sometimes that’s true. But there’s a line between investing in your craft and procrastinating through purchases.

I wasn’t buying synths. I was buying excuses. Every new box let me avoid confronting the fear that maybe, just maybe, the problem wasn’t my tools. It was me. Or more specifically — it was my mindset.

Studio Clutter, Mental Clutter

There’s a real cost to owning too much gear — and it’s not just the price tag. Creative overwhelm is real. Too many options kills flow. When every decision (patch, plugin, preset) spawns ten more, starting a track feels like defusing a bomb.

I started noticing how often I abandoned ideas mid-session because I got distracted dialing in a sound. Not improving it — tweaking for the sake of tweaking. And you know what wasn’t happening while I did that?

Writing music.

Shifting the Mindset: From Collector to Creator

So I started stripping things back. Not to be a minimalist martyr — just to reclaim clarity. I boxed up everything except one synth, one mic, and a handful of go-to plugins. Told myself I wouldn’t add anything back until I’d finished five tracks.

That was six months ago. Not only did I hit the goal — I’m making better music now than I ever did with a wall of gear behind me. Why? Because fewer choices forced decisions, and decisions made room for momentum.

Turns out, finishing music feels way better than shopping for it.

The Question Every Musician Should Ask

If your studio is packed and your output is stalled, ask yourself:

Do I want to be surrounded by music gear, or do I want to be surrounded by my music?

Because one of those looks cool on Instagram. The other sounds amazing in your headphones.

There’s nothing wrong with loving the gear. We all do. But at some point, you have to pick: are you building a studio, or are you building songs?

Only one of them shows up on Spotify.

Marvin Cavanaugh
Marvin Cavanaugh
Marvin Cavanaugh

Written by Marvin Cavanaugh

Marvin Cavanaugh is a veteran music journalist with a background in contemporary music performance from Berklee College of Music. Based in Nashville, he covers the gear, technology, and creative tools shaping modern sound. When he's not writing for Audio Chronicle, he’s usually tweaking pedal chains or crate-digging at local record shops.

Comments

No comments yet.

Marvin Cavanaugh

Written by Marvin Cavanaugh

Marvin Cavanaugh is a veteran music journalist with a background in contemporary music performance from Berklee College of Music. Based in Nashville, he covers the gear, technology, and creative tools shaping modern sound. When he's not writing for Audio Chronicle, he’s usually tweaking pedal chains or crate-digging at local record shops.